Sunday, 4 September 2011

The Glory Days of the Giant Scarborough Tunny



The British Tunny Club, Hardy Bros. tackle and big game fishing in the 1930s
by Mark Ross



What a fantastic book this is. Buy it, borrow it, steal it.....however you get hold of a copy just make sure you get a read of this book if you have even the slightest interest in the subject.

It tells the story of an era long since passed and never to return. During the 1930s huge shoals of herring descended on the British coast every summer. Following closely behind were the bluefin tuna, a fish of immense proportions and reputedly uncatchable on rod and line. What follows are some of the most amazing stories of fishing in British waters you're ever likely to come across. Stories of seven hour battles, boats being towed twenty miles, telegraph pole-like rods being snapped in two, a 763lb tunny being landed by a 12 year old boy only to be refused a certificate by the British Tunny club on a technicality and many more.

All of these stories are set off by hundreds of stunning period photos. The author is also a very keen collector of the old tunny fishing tackle and so there is a great deal of information and hi-res photographs of the kind of tackle being used to tame these huge fish.

Mark Ross has done a very good job of writing this book. It is a bit of a balancing act between a dry book on the history and social history of the Scarborough tunny fishery and the effect it had on the UK and the world; and also an enthralling story of the people involved. On first reading this book I found it very hard to put down, I always had to turn just one more page to see what happened next. Ross, thanks to his extensive research, has brought every character back to life and I found myself getting quite deep into the story.

As mentioned, the author has put a huge amount of research into this book and it really does show. He has turned up huge amounts of original photographs, local, national and international newspaper archives, certificates issued by the British Tunny Club, articles and letters from the Fishing Gazette, various anecdotes and personal accounts and even personal letters between anglers of the time. For the reader wanting to get even further into the subject there are many appendices at the rear of the book plus a bibliography.

Unfortunately the tunny fishing was cut short by the start of the second world war in 1939. For the next six years almost no fishing was done and once the world situation settled down again in 1945 the herring shoals had drifted away and to this day the tuna have never returned to British waters in any real numbers. This book is a glimpse into a fishery I am never likely to see in my lifetime but once existed and despite lasting such a short period has left its mark forever on British fishing history.

This book is the last word on the subject as well as being a fantastic read in its own right. If you are at all interested then I can only suggest you get yourself a copy now while it's still freely available at the cover price of £89. I feel confident that this will set the standard for writing on the history of the Scarborough tunny fishery and will almost certainly become a sought after collector's item in the future. Grab it while you can.

Coch Y Bonddu Books have new copies available for the cover price of £89.

Privately published by the author in 2010. Cloth-bound hardback limited to 250 numbered copies. Deluxe leather-bound edition limited to just 20 copies.

Click here to go back to the list of all reviews.

Barbel Fishing: A Logical Approach

by Tim Lennon 

It's a difficult one this. Tim Lennon is clearly a skilled angler and on his local rivers he has found a technique that catches, catches very well actually. Unfortunately for me that's about the limit of this book. One method on one river, well maybe two. 

That's not to say I didn't enjoy it, I did in fact find it a pretty interesting read and I guess I might be being a little unfair. Much of what the author writes about can be applied to other rivers.... on the condition that you can actually see the fish you are targeting. But then to be perfectly honest, if I can see a shoal of barbel then I generally have little trouble catching them. I'll put my tin hat on before I say this to protect myself from the tins of Spam about to come flying my way, but barbel are surely the easiest fish in the UK to catch, right? 

As I said at the start this book is pretty much entirely about one method. I would have loved it as a guest chapter in another book but I'm not sure it needed an entire book of it's own. It reminds me of my school days when we had to write out our essays to a certain number of words. I procrastinated and rambled on, writing in circles to hit that word count when I could have said everything I needed to in less than half of that. 


The major emphasis throughout is on finding the fish and then spending time building confidence in the shoal before you introduce your hookbait. I won't give away too much detail, you can read the book for the specifics. I'm not sure this warranted an entire book. I also think Lennon is guilty of crediting barbel with far more intelligence than they actually have but then maybe I'm just used to fishing for stupid ones. I've never fished the Hampshire Avon or Dorset Stour so perhaps he's right. If you fish rivers where you generally can't sit and observe the shoal you are fishing for then this book will be of little use to you.


This book commands a fairly decent price on the second hand market and I think that is mainly down to the low numbers it was printed in. There was a small hardback edition limited to just 200 numbered copies plus a paperback run too. The hardbacks usually just about reach three figures though they don't often come up for sale. 

First published in 2004 by PICS Publishing Ltd. "PICS" stands for Paving Industry Contractor Support. No I don't understand why a paving company have published a book about barbel fishing either.

Click here to go back to the list of all reviews.

Saturday, 3 September 2011

A Bibliography of Barbel


Well I feel this bibliography, at the time of writing is pretty complete. If you're into collecting barbel books then you're in luck. There are enough out there to keep you interested, including one or two hard to find ones, yet not so many that your collection will never be complete. There are a few you might struggle with however - William J. Howes 'The Quest for Barbel', a small paperback that rarely comes up for sale and it's even rarer to find it in anything approaching fine condition. Peter Wheat's 'The Fighting Barbel' is usually available but don't expect much change out of £300 for a decent copy. Then of course there's the Trent Otter's 'Barbel and Chub Fishing' first published in 1896. It was reprinted a few years ago by the Medlar Press and even that has become quite hard to find now. I'm still looking for a first...
Click here to go back to the list of all reviews.

    Friday, 2 September 2011

    Coarse Fishing: A Guide To Successful Angling





    Various authors
    introduction by Tom Pickering

    This was one of the first books I bought about fishing. I say bought, what I actually mean is nicked off my brother. I read it so much when I was younger I practically knew if off by heart.

    It may be a book for beginners but there are some top names in the line-up of authors - John Bailey, Chris Ball, Neville Fickling, Jim Gibbinson, Dave Harrell, Martin Hooper, Bob James, Peter Mohan, Andy Orme, Barrie Rickards and John Watson to name but a few.

    It is divided into four main chapters - Techniques and tackle, Baits and lures, Know your fish and A specialist approach. Each chapter is then broken down into many smaller sections dealing with specific subjects. There really is something for everyone here, from bloodworm and joker fishing on the whip to drifting deadbaits for pike on Scottish lochs. Every aspect of coarse fishing gets a mention. The section on freelining by Bob James pretty much turned me into the fisherman I was to become, with Barrie Rickards' words on lure fishing seeing me through the winter months. The 'specialist approach' chapter got most of my attention.

    If you are new to coarse fishing or you know someone who is then this book is well worth tracking down. The magazine article style format of each section makes it very clear and easy to read. Yes it's nearly 20 years old now, but being about A4 in size, over 220 pages, with full colour photographs and illustrations on every page this book is crammed full of information, the vast majority of which is still perfectly relevant today. Thoroughly recommended.

    Coch Y Bonddu Books should have no trouble finding you a copy and it won't cost a great deal.

    First published by Collins Willow in 1992. This review was written after reading the 1993 Colour Library Books reprint.

    Click here to go back to the list of all reviews.

    Spoonplugging


    by E.L. "Buck" Perry


    Instructional books on fishing are normally little more than a good cure for insomnia. I've read a thousand times how to tie a knot, create a hair-rig, shot a float and cast a fly. Unless someone points out to me that I've been doing it wrong all these years then I really don't need to read it again, thanks anyway. Spoonplugging is an instructional book. However, if you lose interest here then you will miss out on one of the most important books available for the thinking angler.

    On the face of it this is simply another book, among hundreds, telling me how to catch largemouth bass in American lakes. Entirely irrelevant to me really being as I am an angler living in Britain with no intention of a fishing trip to the States anytime soon. But this book is hiding a lot more than a glance at the front cover might reveal.

    Firstly, this is not a book of methods. If you want to be shown specific methods on how to fish then this is not the book for you, though there are a thousand others out there that will give you what you need. What this book does best is make you think. Throughout the text Perry will force you to think about why you are fishing in the way you are. Why did you choose that lure? Why did you cast there? Why did you pack up at that time of day? Why did you choose that part of the lake? To be frank, the book asks a lot more questions than it truly answers, but that's the point. This is a book to be read, considered, and read again.

    Lure anglers are the magpies of the angling world. We know that really there is no magic lure that attracts fish like a magnet but we still keep buying them in the hope we find it. Every new lure that comes out has to be bought because you just never know. Perry helps reinforce the knowledge (that really we already know) that the lure plays a very small role in catching the fish. Wrong lure in the right spot is better than the right lure in the wrong spot. Simple, I know, but it's surprising how easy that can be to forget. Whilst the book is really dealing with lure fishing, the principles involved can be transferred to all other angling disciplines.

    To be honest, I found Spoonplugging to be quite a hard read. That may be due to the overpowering American-ness (if that's a word) in the way it was written or simply because of the massive amount of information contained within its pages. It is however well worth reading and I would thoroughly recommend it to anyone looking for a more advanced instructional book, lure and fly anglers in particular.

    Spoonplugging doesn't often come up for sale in this country. My copy was purchased through Coch Y Bonddu Books who occasionally get them in second hand. Failing that, look to America to source a copy.

    First published in 1965 as a 32 page booklet. This review was written after reading the considerably revised and enlarged edition (now around 300 pages) of 1973, basically an entirely new book.

    Click here to go back to the list of all reviews.

    River Fly-Fishing: The Complete Guide


    by Peter Lapsley

    If you are after a  beginner's guide to fly fishing in rivers then you need look no further than this. Contained within its 200+ pages is everything you need to know and nothing more. Lapsley gets straight to the point and doesn't ramble on about the unnecessary bits of information that the average angler simply doesn't need.

    Everything is covered - a brief history of flyfishing, where to fish and what species to fish for, what fish eat, how to tackle up, how to cast, how to approach the different seasons, dry flies, nymphs, wet flies, sea trout, grayling and a look at the future of the sport.

    Illustrated with black and white line drawings and colour plates, the book is easy to read and follows a neatly arranged format. If you are after a specific piece of information then it is always easy to find. There is little more to say really. If you are after a beginner's guide to the subject then this is most certainly one of, if not the best.

    Coch Y Bonddu Books are usually able to supply both the standard and special editions.

    First published in 2003 by Robert Hale. A special edition in quarter bound leather and limited to sixty signed and numbered copies was also produced.

    Click here to go back to the list of all reviews.

    The Domesday Book of Mammoth Pike


    by Fred Buller

    A quick note about book collecting. Quality + Rarity = ££££££

    Many people seem to think that rarity is the most important factor in the high prices of some second-hand books. In my mind that is simply not the case. Quality plays an enormous part in the equation. Crap rare books can be worth quite a small amount as only serious book collectors (I must have everything!!! types) want them to be taking up valuable space on the shelf. Books with excellent content will hold their value better even if they aren't anywhere near as rare as others, this is simply because everyone wants to buy them.

    Apologies if that seems a little patronising but the amount of times I've heard "...but only 300 copies were printed. I'll buy a dozen and retire off the proceeds!" meant I wanted to put that myth to bed. If you're looking for a good investment then make sure it's a good book in the first place.

    Fred Buller's 'Domesday Book of Mammoth Pike' fits the bill perfectly. It is relatively rare (though not especially) and it is a good book. Well actually it's a great book. Unfortunately if you don't own one already then I'm afraid you've missed the boat on searching out a good investment as nowadays they command a pretty high price. A signed hardback in excellent nick will set you back the best part of £600. Paperbacks can be got a fair bit cheaper.

    What makes it great? Well the amount of time and effort that must have gone into the research of this book is simply astounding. Buller has compiled a record of 230 pike caught over the past 250 years. Each one of which was over 35lbs in weight. The biggest pike in the book? Well you'll have to get hold of a copy and find out for yourself.

    This could have been written as a rather dry list but thankfully it has been fleshed out quite a bit. Each entry has as many details of the capture as the author could gather and most have a good back story too.

    There are several criticisms of this book. The first of which is that a great deal of the content is a work of fiction. Well this is almost certainly true. Stories of Irish pike weighing 90lbs+ are a little hard to believe. The author has included them though so that the reader can make up his own mind. In a lot of cases it is of course very hard to prove either way the true weight of a pike. Take for example entry number 42 - Tommy Morgan's Scottish record pike of 47lb 11oz. A fish which to this day provokes heated debate from believers and disbelievers. Read the book through but do take some of the entries with a pinch of salt.

    The second criticism is that Buller has included ALL pike no matter how they were caught. This includes fish that have been caught illegally, netted or found dead. I can't understand this train of thought. I see this book as a record of the potential size that pike can attain. It matters little to me whether the fish was caught on rod and line or found washed up dead on the bank. Simply to know that a 40lb pike once existed in a river or lake not too far from me is all I want. Stories of fish like these are what get me out of bed and out fishing despite the wind and rain lashing against the window on a cold February day.

    The final criticism is that every pike photographed is dead. I can't really defend that other than to say that's what happened in those days. The book was published in 1979 and at that time and before, catch and release of pike just didn't happen. If you don't like pictures of dead pike then don't buy it. It didn't put me off though.

    All in all, Fred Buller has created arguably the most inspiring collection of big pike stories ever put together, before or since. A copy of this should be on the shelf of every serious piker as well as those who just like a good read.

    Coch Y Bonddu Books regularly have copies of the hardback and paperback editions available.

    First published in 1979 by Stanley Paul & Co. Printed simultaneously in both hardback and paperback.

    Click here to go back to the list of all reviews.